“What’s in a name? That which we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet”
So said Juliet as she sat on the balcony pondering her fate.And we all know how that turned out, don’t we?You may have gathered that I had to wait a while for Carl to pluck up the courage/pull his finger out and pop the question. We’d been together 6 1/2 years when he proposed last summer and by the time I walk down the aisle we’ll have celebrated our 8 year anniversary (24 hours before the ceremony to be precise!).
I’d love to tell you that I waited patiently all those years, elegant to the end, and at peace with our unmarried, yet deeply committed, status as a family.
But if I did, I’d be lying.
So I’m going to come right out and admit it.
I nagged.
Not constantly, you understand, but enough to get my point across.
One of the things that bothered me most during those years of living in sin (!) was the fact that I had a different surname to the children.
They’re Shanahans you see, like their father. It’s an exclusive club of 3 in our house, and I really hated being the odd one out.
When Isabel was born it didn’t occur to me to give her any other surname. Carl was her father and I think I wanted him to have a sense of ‘ownership’ over her, believing that it might make the whole thing seem somehow more real, more permanent.
It wasn’t until after she was born that I realised that my not being a Shanahan made things a little complicated. On more than one occasion, I was asked to provide documentary evidence of the fact I was her mother and I came to resent being asked to ‘clarify my relationship to the child in question’.
That said, I wasn’t about to give her baby brother a different surname, as if one child belonged to me and the other to Carl. So two little Shanahans they are.
I remember being sat at the dinner table one evening with the children, some months before we were engaged, listening to Izzy say ‘I’m a Shanahan, Jesse’s a Shanahan, Daddy’s a Shanahan BUT Mummy is a LEON. You’re the only LEON Mummy. Why aren’t you a Shanahan Mummy, why, why, why?’
Adorable, no?
But Isabel had hit a nerve, I was sick of being the only Leon.
The rational part of my brain was completely aware that it’s just a name but another part of me felt slighted every time I looked at my signature.
So you can imagine my confusion at the fact that now, with just 9 months to go before the big day, I’ve suddenly started feeling very possessive over those precious 4 letters that are my surname.
I am Franky Leon and, suddenly, the thought of being anything else horrifies me.
A few years ago I relished being mistaken for Mrs Shanahan by hotel receptionists and the like. I’d fail to set them straight, giggle and grin at Carl knowingly. Now, I jump to correct them before they can finish their sentence.
If I say ‘Mrs Shanahan’ out loud it makes me feel like I’m Carl’s mother. I’m convinced people are going to start asking me if I’m Irish (not that there’s anything wrong with being Irish it’s just that I’m not) and when I practice my future signature (lovesick teenager styleee, repeatedly in my exercise book) it just looks plain ugly. There’s too many letters and I can’t make the h’s look pretty.
Heck, sometimes I can’t even spell the damn thing.
So if I like Leon so much why I don’t I just keep it? Or hyphenate it perhaps?
Shanahan-Leon.
Leon-Shanahan.
Kind of a mouthful don’t you think?
What’s in a name?
Well Juliet, quite a lot actually.
Loveaudrey xxx

Ah yes, the sounding like his Mum thing. I know this well. Despite hating my own last name (Cragg- it’s so harsh sounding) and being very excited about become Rosalyn Hogan, I feel exactly the same now and realise it’s actually a big part of who I am and have been for 26 years (it will be 27 by the time we get hitched). That said, I will take his name and I’m sure I will get used to it, in time. I think hyphenating can work well especially as your kids are already Shanahans. I always worry what would happen if our kids had a double barelled name and then got married- would they have 3 last names?! Craziness! xx
So funny you should write this – I’m exactly the same!
I’ve always said that whilst I don’t have a problem in the slightest with children born to unmarried parents, I would feel kind of weird to have a different surname to my children so for us, marriage was always going to preceed children.
I absolutely can’t wait to be a Mrs Karney – the existing and former Mrs Karneys are all extremely formidable characters (his aunts, mother and late grandmother) and it will be an honour to become one and be part of their family.
BUT… my name is Bishop. For 30 years it’s been Bishop. All my friends call me variations of my surname – Bish, Bishy etc…. and in 14 months my NAME is going to change.
It’s all rather scary really. But exciting! xx
Haha this made me laugh. My Dad wants me to hyphenate my name but that’s just torture on our future children as we both have names that usually need to be spelled out. Laura Purvis-Carnegie. Now THAT my dear is a mouthful lol.
My sister in law had the same worries as you, so although she was engaged when she had her baby, she didn’t want to be the odd one out. She hyphenated by deed-poll so that she had part of the same surname as the baby, and she will drop her maiden name next week when she gets married and becomes a fully-fledged Bailey.
It is a very personal decision but for me, part of being married is taking the surname. Being a ‘Mrs’ is what scares me though – makes me seem old!!
Lots of love xxx
Ah I totally get where you’re coming from! When I get married I will be Dani Dunne (hurrah for alliteration, good thing I’m a literature student) but the idea of being “Mrs Dunne”…it just sounds so bizarre! And I’ve spent years perfecting the squiggle that is my signature, how on earth am I meant to change it now? Don’t get me wrong, though, I can’t wait to be married…it’ll just take a lot of getting used to, losing my name like that! I like the idea of hyphenating though, for you I think that would definitely be the way to go! (for me, not so much, our last names don’t “go” at all)
xx
@Primp & Preen Hogan is a lovely surname! You get a good switch like my Mum, she traded Hogg for Leon! After they seperated she didn’t want to revert back to her maiden name (for obviuos reasons) so she kept the Leon until she remarried. I’m glad I’m not alone in feeling a little sentimental about my surname though!
@Emma I really wasn’t prepared for how much it bothered me and I totally understand you wanting to be married before popping out any babies. Karney is a cool name though! I wonder about the whole nickname thing too. Carl always calls me ‘Leon’ and I think he probably always will! You’re right, of course, it’s scary and exciting!
@Lollipop Yes, being a Mrs will make me feel old!! I think I’m the same and ultimately I will become a Shanahan, I’m just having a hard time getting my head round it!
@Dani Loving the alliteration! AND there’s potential for a ‘Double D’ nickname 🙂
xxx
I totally sympathise! I am too used to being Sophie Neve (even though no one can spell it, I get Neave, Neeve, and my friends call me ‘Naive’ and ‘Nerve.’) I told the ball and chain in a drunken moment that if we ever got married, I’d be keeping my last name – and he got really insulted and we ended up having an argument! He’s quite traditional and although the (inactive) feminist in me rails against a name change for all sorts of good reasons, I can kind of see from a guy’s point of view why they would look forward to installing their woman in their lives as ‘Mrs …’ I’m sure Carl will find he loves having a Mrs Shanahan by his side! But I will end up being Sophie Rainger (if he stays in my good books) which makes me cringe every time I think about it, and sounds very plain and English compared to the Italian of Neve.
I’m sure you’ll find once you have the name you like it, or you can continue to use your maiden name casually and just crack out the married name for credit cards etc. xxx
A really thought inspring post!
I’m kinda the same- my surname starts with a letter quite late in the alphabet so when I was younger, I always wanted to change it. Now that I’m a bit older, I’ve grown really attached to it and can’t imagine having a different surname.
I guess your name is such a big part of your identity, that it’s hard to imagine being called something else after all these years! x
I’m very attached to my surname and can’t bear to part with it! If I took my fiance’s surname it would kinda feel like I wasn’t a proper part of MY family anymore, and we’re very close. I have 3 older brothers, 1 of which is married and 1 is engaged, and it made me feel funny to think that there would be all these new Mrs Low’s and I wouldn’t be one if I took my fiance’s name.
So we’re going double-barrelled. My fiance and I want to have the same name, along with our future children, so he’ll be changing his surname too. We’re so excited about it, we’ll be our own little family unit but still belong to both our families, I can’t wait! He loves jokingly referring to us as the powerhouse Parkin-Low’s! And I love that I can look forward to changing my name as gaining a part of my identity instead of losing part of it.
xx
I was talking about this with my Mum yesterday! I am hugely bothered by the fact that Jamie and I have different surnames, as his Mother I don’t want to have a different name, I don’t want to think about the awkward moments when people realise. It’s not that I feel judged, I just feel I should have the same surname, and I WANT to! However, I’ve been with Colin for the same amount of time as you’ve been with Carl, and my nagging has yet to pay off…hehe!
I actually quite like Shanahan-Leon, I think it has a very nice ring to it, but at the end of the day, give this a lot more thought, talk about it with Carl and ultimately come to a decision you’re both comfortable with. I love both of your surnames, but can certainly identify with you – Leon is YOU, Boakes is ME, it’s a lot more important the minute you think about losing it, right?! xxx
Aw I loved this post!
I’m glad to see that I’m not the only woman nagging. I’ve been with my fella for 7 years this coming August, I hope to be sporting a ring for next summer otherwise some strong words will be had!
I completely understand where you’re coming from with the name – my partner’s surname is Singh so I think my name would change to Kaur which is the female equivalent in Sikh culture. I’m not even sure quite how it works and neither is he.
I don’t think Morrison-Kaur or Morrison-Singh would really work so I’m going to need to get my head around the change and get to understanding it!
Of course this is all a bit premature since I’m still waiting for the ring!
Tx